|
Green Product Certification:
A Guide To Maintaining Sales
|
Green Product Standards Explained
Standards, Certifications and Programs
What is Green Seal?
-
Green Seal (www.greenseal.org)
is an independent organization that provides 3rd
party "green" certification to
various products and services.
-
Approved products carry
a Green Seal logo that is well recognized throughout industry and government
as a leading environmental standard.
-
Manufacturers pay Green
Seal a fee for each product that is reviewed for certification. In addition to
complying with Green Seal standards, manufacturers of approved products are
subject to ongoing factory inspections (at the manufacturer’s expense),
product testing and annual maintenance fees.
-
The Green Seal standard
for industrial & institutional cleaning products, including general purpose,
bathroom, glass and carpet cleaners, is known as
GS-37.
In order to receive certification, a product must:
-
Be sold in concentrated form
-
Contain recyclable packaging
-
Pass a cleaning efficacy test
-
Remain non-corrosive to skin or eyes
-
Pass oral, inhalation, dermal and aquatic toxicity tests
-
Pass a biodegradability test
-
Exclude prohibited ingredients - including heavy metals,
alkylphenol ethoxylates, dibutyl phthalate, ozone depleting chemicals and
IARC listed chemicals
What is DfE?
-
DfE (www.epa.gov/dfe)
is a "formulator initiative" program developed by the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) in conjunction with the GreenBlue institute. DfE is
not a true standard or certification program. They simply "recognize" you.
Like Green Seal, DfE has a logo for products to carry.
-
DfE provides
manufacturers with a database of preferred cleaning ingredients to make
products "greener." Each ingredient in the database has a detailed "profile"
including hazard information and human/environmental toxicology.
-
Manufacturers submitting
products for approval must release a confidential, full ingredient disclosure
to DfE. If ingredients in a submitted product’s formula are not already
included in DfE’s database, it is necessary to pay a 3rd
party outside lab to develop the
ingredient's chemical profile and submit it to DfE.
-
There is no fee for
ingredients already in the database. Additionally, the manufacturer does not
pay a certification fee for DfE (unlike Green Seal).
-
A Green Seal certified
product may or may not achieve DfE approval, and vice-versa.
What is Environmental Choice?
-
Environmental Choice,
like Green Seal, is a 3rd
party green certification service.
Members must pay submission fees and annual licensing fees. Members are also
subject to an on-site factory audit. Approved products carry the Environmental
Choice logo. Product approval criteria are very similar to Green Seal.
Mutual Recognition Agreement - Green Seal & Environmental Choice
Green Seal and Environmental Choice have a mutual recognition
agreement. This makes it easier and cheaper for a Green Seal product to get
Environmental Choice approval, and vice-versa.
-
Products
are evaluated only based on the differences between the two standards. This
means less cost as there is not as many tests required.
-
The on-site audit for
either Green Seal or Environmental Choice is acceptable to the other. No need
for two!
Differences Evaluated


LEED Program
The United States Green Building Council (USGBC) is a
not-for-profit established in 1993 that is dedicated to promoting the
construction, maintenance, and certification of sustainable buildings (green
buildings). The council is considered to be a national consensus due to their
diversity of membership, which includes representatives in the following fields:
architects, attorneys, builders/contractors, consultants, corporations, retail
businesses, engineers, federal/state/local agencies, lending institutions,
interior designers, landscape architects, city planners, environmental
organizations, universities, media, and utilities companies. In 1998 the USGBC
launched the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) program which
established a rating system to identify and certify green buildings.
The LEED program is a consensus based, market driven building
rating system based on existing proven technology. It evaluates a building’s
environmental performance (inside and out) from a whole building perspective
using life cycle analysis. This system provides a definitive standard for what
constitutes a "green building". Certification can be obtained for new
construction projects as well as existing buildings and homes. It is a
performance-oriented system where points are earned for satisfying criteria.
Different levels of certification can be achieved based on the number of points
earned as follows:
-
Certified 32-39 points
-
Silver 40-47 points
-
Gold 48-63 points
-
Platinum 64-85 points
There are six categories, or aspects, of green buildings for
which points can be earned in the LEED program.
-
"Sustainable Sites"
Deals with the preservation and
restoration of the ecology around a building. Landscaping and planting
decisions can affect the amount of irrigation water and fertilizer required in
addition to other things that impact local environments. The design of
buildings, parking lots, etc, can impact storm water management and can
contribute to the "urban heat island effect". Sedimentation that results from
construction and landscaping activities around buildings can greatly affect
local water quality. Excess use of external lighting can be disruptive to the
lives of nocturnal animals and wastes energy. There are 14 possible points
that can be obtained in this category.
-
"Water Efficiency"
America’s use of water is increasing.
The US Geological Survey estimates that between 1990 and 2000 our fresh water
use increased by 12% to 43.3 billion gallons per day. Use of water in
buildings is second only to the generation of thermoelectric power and
agriculture. The increased demand for fresh water has caused water levels in
underground aquifers to drop by 150 feet since the 1940’s. All but 14% of this
water is used, treated, and discharged to our nation’s water bodies. The goal
of LEED is to make green buildings sustainable water users by evaluating all
water usage and implementing controls and conservation strategies. There are 5
possible points that can be achieved here.
-
"Energy and Atmosphere"
This category deals with a building’s
use of energy and the pollution/environmental damage that is caused by the
generation of this energy. In 2003 the US generated 3,961 billion kilowatt
hours of electricity. Thirty two percent of this was used to heat, cool, and
light commercial buildings. Energy costs are a significant operating expense
and major concern for any building owner. Coal fired plants accounted for 53%
of the electricity generated in 2003. Each kilowatt hour of electricity
produced in this way generates around 250 pounds of green house gasses, in
addition to the pollution and environmental damage caused by mining and
transporting the coal. Economical and readily achievable practices can greatly
reduce the amount of energy used by commercial buildings. There are 23
possible points that can be achieved here.
-
"Materials and
Resources" Buildings create a
large amount of waste through their operations and maintenance. Waste can be
avoided by implementing plans that will (1) carefully choose the materials
that are allowed to come into the building, keeping environmental impacts and
the ultimate fate of the material in mind and (2) that manage the materials
that leave the building in a way as to minimize land-filling and incineration.
Source reduction of waste is a key priority. There are 16 points that can be
earned in this category.
-
"Indoor Environmental Quality"
People in the US spend most of their
time (90% or more…) indoors. Combine this with studies released by the EPA on
the poor quality of our indoor air, and you have a serious problem. On average
indoor air is 2-5 times more polluted than outside air. This is due to
legislation passed back in the 70’s that required building manufacturers to
produce more energy efficient structures. The easiest way to do this is to
make buildings “tighter”, reducing the number of air exchanges with the
outside. We must now spend more money on expensive HVAC systems to circulate
our air. Chemicals and particles introduced into a building can build up over
time to toxic levels under these circumstances. Much of the problem comes from
the building materials themselves, containing chemical treatments and
preservatives that are slowly released into the air. Moisture buildup due to
poor ventilation makes the problem worse by accelerating the growth of mold,
which is associated with asthma and allergic reactions. Building Related
Illness (BRI) and Sick Building Syndrome (SBS) are relatively new problems for
building owners and cause an estimated $180 billion in annual business losses
due to absenteeism and "presenteeism". Presenteeism is a buzzword for the loss
of productivity that results when people show up sick to work (resulting in
more sick workers). This is where Spray Nine can help, by offering cleaning
products with a greatly reduced ability to impact indoor air quality. There
are 22 points that be achieved in this category.
-
"Innovation in Upgrades, Operation, and Maintenance"
This is an abbreviated category that
allows up to five points to be awarded for clever or unique approaches to
reducing environmental impacts that may not be addressed in the rest of the
standard.
Green Cleaning and LEED:
Cleaning is a sub-part of the IAQ category and the Materials and
Resources category, and is further broken down into the following:
-
1 Point-
"Entryway Systems" Involves the use of mats and grates to reduce the amount of
dirt, dust, pollen, and other particles in the first place. A written
maintenance plan should be kept that demonstrates the strategy and cleaning
techniques for keeping halls and entryways clean, and quarterly reports that
document the performance of the plan. This can greatly reduce the need,
frequency, energy consumed in, and chemical used during cleaning in the rest of
the building and is often overlooked in conventional buildings.
-
1 Point- "Isolation of
Janitorial Closets" This means that the janitorial closet should be separated
from the plumbing and air ventilation system of the rest of the building.
These areas should have negative air pressure provided by a separate outside
exhausting, and should have drains designed to separate waste liquids from the
rest of the buildings water waste for disposal. Requires a written program
covering the procedures for mixing and storing cleaning and maintenance
chemicals, as well as security procedures to keep unauthorized personnel from
coming into contact with chemicals.
-
2 Points- "Low
Environmental Impact Pest Management Policy" A plan should be in place to
identify and encourage the use of alternative Integrated Pest Management (IPM)
techniques designed to reduce reliance on chemicals. This includes sanitation
procedures, building maintenance schedules, regular pest inspections, and
evaluations of any chemicals that may be required to identify those with the
least impacts. When applying any pesticide on sight, the building occupants
must be alerted so those individuals that may be sensitive can remove
themselves.
-
1 Point- "Low
Environmental Impact Cleaning Equipment Policy" This entails the use of energy
efficient and low noise/vibration producing equipment. Machines that have
variable speeds should be used so that only the right amount of energy is
expended for a job (no overkill). Includes a plan for the training of
maintenance personnel.
-
1-3 Points- "Sustainable
Cleaning Products and Materials" This includes cleaning products purchased for
in-house use, and those used by cleaning services. For each 30% (cost) of
cleaning chemical products purchased that either meet the Green Seal GS-37
standard, or if a GS category standard does not exist for the product it must
meet the California Code of Regulations maximum allowable VOC content levels (CARB).
Disposable janitorial goods such as paper towels and trash bags must meet the
minimum requirements of the EPA’s Comprehensive Procurement Guidelines, which
specify recommended amounts of post consumer recycled content that products
should contain.
Scientific Certification System (SCS):
SCS is an internationally recognized third party evaluation and
certification organization. Its programs span the economy and include mostly
agriculture, energy, manufactured goods, forestry, and fisheries. SCS also
conducts a program that verifies the accuracy of environmental claims on
product, including cleaning products. SCS only certifies the following four
single environmental attribute claims for cleaning products: VOC content,
biodegradability, recycled content, and no formaldehyde. Each of these
attributes would have to be pursued independently.
NSF Environmentally Preferable Products - Hard Surface Cleaners:
The National Sanitation Foundation (NSF) is a non-profit,
non-governmental organization that is recognized for its standards development,
product certification, education, and risk management for public health and
safety. NSF is working on a soon to be finalized standard on EPP: Hard
Surface Cleaners.
The draft standard establishes requirements for a product
development process that can be included in an environmental management system (PDP-EMS).
A hard surface cleaner developed with this process that meets the requirements
of the standard will be considered EPP. The draft of the standard addresses
pollution prevention and responsible energy use throughout the life cycle of the
product by systematically integrating environmental considerations into every
step of the product design process. This standard attempts to contribute to the
goal of ultimate sustainability by evaluating and addressing significant
environmental impacts associated with each product life cycle stage such as:
-
Raw material acquisition
-
Manufacturing process
-
Package selection and
design
-
Distribution
-
Use and performance of
the product
-
Disposal of product and
packaging
Participating in this certification program represents a
commitment to continual environmental improvement in each product life cycle
stage. The draft, in its current form, establishes a framework by which a
company can assess its current environmental footprint, set specific
environmental goals, and measure its environmental progress.
Standards Used by Federal Agencies
-
Agency-Specific
Standards
-
Green Seal Standards
-
Navy Standards for
Surface Ship Cleaning
-
Recycled Content and
Biobased Content Recommendations
To Source "Green" Cleaners That Really Work
Contact Spray Nine Corporation (1-800-477-7299) for more
information on our new "Adirondack Green" Line. These products meet
environmental guidelines while outperforming the competition.
Spray Nine Corporation
web site: www.spraynine.com
Adirondack Green green
cleaners web site:
www.adirondackgreen.com
|
|